Tuesday, 25 November 2014 00:00

Billboard: Judge Rules Against Pandora in Licensing Fight

Written by

Last Friday, November 21, BMI rate court judge Louis L. Stanton, ruled against Pandora’s motion on a license-in-effect with the performance right society.Pandora

Billboard reported that the judge said that there was no license-in-effect because Pandora was not yet a license holder. BMI senior VP and general counsel, Stuart Rosen, confirmed that though Pandora could use the music, the digital service was still an applicant for a license and would not become a license holder until the rate and length of the deal were determined.

Pandora argued that it needed Stanton to rule on a motion that the service possessed a license-in-effect because, without the order, Pandora’s blanket license would be less-valuable than every other licensee that has come before BMI’s rate court. Furthermore, the digital service contended that BMI and its publishing affiliates have used a license-in-effect stance once a license is issued to a digital service. When the PRO issued this license, all BMI repertory would be locked in so when publishers contemplated withdrawal for licenses to digital services, ongoing licenses were protected and only expiring licenses were allowed for debate.

Beyond these points, Pandora argued that the PROs would also benefit from the license-in-effect stance because it would provide stability for its members by helping the companies to “allocate costs among affiliates while locking in steady royalty streams.” Pandora pushed that it would be “senseless to allow BMI to change the nature and scope of the license.”

Pandora’s rate trial to determine the rate and length of their license from BMI has been scheduled to begin February 9. The parties will negotiate how to deal with publishers leaving BMI and how that will impact the decided rate.

Search MS101

Buy The Book On Amazon

SCH10174 Music Supervision

Twitter Feed @MusicSupervise

For Content Producers

Need the perfect song for your visuals?
Try our FREE service!

The SongHunters

Do you need a Music Supervisor for just an hour?
Try the HourlyMusicSupervisors

SongHunters Testimonials

  • "The SongHunters have helped license our music into the right markets and video games with ease. They did all of the groundwork for us which is very important - especially for an independent band. The SongHunters have brought the rest of the world closer to us and that is what truly matters."
    We Outspoken

Newsletter Sign-up

Subscribe to our Music Supervision 101 / SongHunters Newsletter!
(Not the same as our SongHunters'
Providers List)

Our Book:

Music Supervision 2: The Complete Guide to Selecting Music for Movies, TV, Games, & New Media

SCH10174 Music Supervision

Available at Amazon.com

The newly revised, definitive book on music supervision, which guides you through real-world scenarios and legal landmines, explores sound design, and profiles key players.

Music supervision, or matching music to all the different mediums from films to ring tones, is one of the fastest-growing careers in the music industry, but finding the winning song for a national ad campaign or compiling a platinum movie soundtrack takes more than just good taste. Music supervision today requires serious multi-tasking and the ability to navigate licensing, relationships, and cultural trends with ease. This book guides you through real scenarios and legal landmines you might encounter; it explores sound design and profiles key players with insightful interviews, while providing project form templates that will save time for seasoned music supervisors.

This is the only guide to the career of music supervision and is ideal for the music student, musician, industry executive and of course, for those who want to break into the field of music supervision. Authors David Weiss, Ramsay Adams and David Hnatiuk are all renowned figures in the procurement and supervision of music and they apply their combined knowledge and experience to give the best possible advice and tell you how to get the job!